The following letter by ITLA President Sara M. Salger was published in the Chicago Tribune on June 3, 2025.
Corporations’ bottom line
Those trying to tip the scales of justice against individuals in favor of wealthy and powerful businesses have long cited — and mischaracterized — the McDonald’s hot coffee case to support their push to close courthouse doors to individuals hurt due to no fault of their own.
Robert Tyson continued that practice in his column (“Sequel to 1994 McDonald’s hot coffee case is now $47 million more expensive, May 27th”) by failing to share that the $2.9 million dollar verdict awarded to a woman who suffered horrific injuries after scalding hot coffee spilled on her lap, was later reduced to $640,000.
The myth of the McDonald’s case suggests the restaurant giant was victimized by an unscrupulous plaintiff. But the truth is that the case proves the system works: the trial judge reduced the damages awarded by the jury and the parties later settled for a confidential amount.